FlytrapCare Carnivorous Plant Forums

Sponsored by FlytrapStore.com

Discussions on how to propagate your plants sexually and asexually, by seed, natural division or leaf pulling

Moderator: Matt

User avatar
By Bluefire
Location: 
Posts:  599
Joined:  Thu Jun 30, 2022 4:58 pm
#427348
So, of my last request to the seed bank (November, I wanted to try it out and there were bonuses), very little sprouted. I got a few tiny capes and 3 Drosophyllum so far. And of the seeds I create myself through breeding my Pings, I have managed to sprout some but the seedlings quickly died (don't know why).

So I doubt I'll be requesting seeds anytime soon, which leaves the question of what to do with the seeds I create. I like breeding my plants, and I'd like to see what I could create. But if I can't sprout or keep any alive, what's the point? I'm wondering if I should host a giveaway of the various Pinguicula seeds I've made through crosses at some point.
By Sundews69
Location: 
Posts:  2388
Joined:  Fri Dec 03, 2021 5:57 pm
#427351
You could plant half of them and give the rest away. This way there is a chance you get plants still . I know some people (myself included) would love some ping seeds for pingdoms
Camden liked this
User avatar
By Camden
Location: 
Posts:  1585
Joined:  Mon May 23, 2022 9:25 pm
#427416
Yeah, I mean I sure would appreciate some ping seeds as well as a lot of other people on the forum if you haven’t any use for them. Maybe do a 50/50 thing between the seed bank and giveaways so that everyone gets a bite at them.
Sundews69 liked this
User avatar
By ChefDean
Location: 
Posts:  8306
Joined:  Tue Sep 18, 2018 12:44 am
#427420
I'm in the same boat you are, my track record with seeds is horrible. I can't get much other than Capes and filiformis to germinate and grow. I did have a few Sarrs seem to survive this last round, but we'll see come springtime.
User avatar
By Bluefire
Location: 
Posts:  599
Joined:  Thu Jun 30, 2022 4:58 pm
#427421
elaineo: I've always just sprinkled the seeds onto moist growing medium and let things sit. I suppose I'll give that a try with this newest batch and see what happens. A classmate got me a blooming Ping for Christmas so I immediately bred it with my P. agnata "True Blue". Seedpods are beginning to form.

ChefDean: I am a notorious Sarracenia killer. I should never be let near any of them. As with all outdoor plants, I sit it outside and forget about it. Unlike other outdoor plants, Sarracenias cannot be left alone in the dry Arizona air. I do best with high maintenance plants that I have to constantly pay attention to, otherwise I simply forget they exist and once I remember, I become too guilty to check.
ChefDean, elaineo liked this
User avatar
By DragonsEye
Posts:  1196
Joined:  Sat Oct 01, 2016 1:22 pm
#427433
Bluefire wrote: Sun Jan 01, 2023 5:17 am elaineo: I've always just sprinkled the seeds onto moist growing medium and let things sit. I suppose I'll give that a try with this newest batch and see what happens?
You might try covering the seeded pot with a transparent plastic lid or plastic wrap. (Covering probably would not have to be terribly tight fitting .) Perhaps the increased humidity would help.

In any event, the seedbank does give you the opportunity to try plants you otherwise might not be able to. If you don't succeed, bummer but little lost. If you do succeed, then you can pat yourself on the back and admire the lil babies you have growing.
Bluefire wrote: Sun Jan 01, 2023 5:17 amChefDean: I am a notorious Sarracenia killer. I should never be let near any of them. As with all outdoor plants, I sit it outside and forget about it. Unlike other outdoor plants, Sarracenias cannot be left alone in the dry Arizona air. I do best with high maintenance plants that I have to constantly pay attention to, otherwise I simply forget they exist and once I remember, I become too guilty to check.
I understand the forgetting... it's easy to do. But you could try leaving yourself reminders on you phone, computer, planner, sticky note in the middle of you computer screen or bathroom mirror, etc. Whatever works best for you. Just some place you will notice the note and find it hard to ignore. I grow the few Sarrs I have in standing water. They summer on my balcony so they are easier to notice. I check them once/wk to see if more water needs added to their "basins". Considering where you live, I imagine you'd have to check several times/wk.
User avatar
By Bluefire
Location: 
Posts:  599
Joined:  Thu Jun 30, 2022 4:58 pm
#427436
The second time I tried sprouting Pinguicula, I put the pot with seeds into a plastic bag. I got sprouts, but they died almost immediately thereafter.

And yeah, summer here is nasty hot. I've been wanting since I got here to go back up north, but unfortunately my parents like being control freaks.
User avatar
By Intheswamp
Location: 
Posts:  2369
Joined:  Wed May 04, 2022 2:28 pm
#427510
Well, unfortunately, some of your comments make me feel better at my feeble attempts at growing seedlings. I guess misery loves company, eh?

Seems mine usually will germinate, some will die off, and the remaining ones are just malingerers...staying small, not hardly growing. I give them a wee bit of Maxsea on occasion, but they still seem to just sit there...laughing at me and calling me bad names. The largest seedlings I've grown are about an inch tall now and were started months ago...from some d. filiformis Florida Red/white-flower that Chef sent me. I thought I wasn't going to get much out of them but I've got probably seven or eight of them going now. Most every other variety of seedlings that I've germinated has dwindled in number of seedlings and those still living have remained small. The seedlings will germinate, somewhat, but then just seem to sit there.

I've mostly started all my seeds in pots of 50:50 peat/perlite with a 1/4" or so deep layer of sifted 100% peat moss. I surprisingly had some d. brevifolia to sprout from seed in a pot where the newly planted parent plants had died off but had dropped seeds. I'm considering going with a heavier sand mix if I can find some suitable sand. Maybe I'll start trying two pots of each variety...maybe the 50:50 peat/perlite and a more sandy 30:70 or similar peat/sand mix. I've seen capillaris and brevifolia growing in sandy soil with dark organic matter mingled in whereas I've seen filiformis in spongy sphagnum moss. Maybe focus more on trying to replicate the natural growing medium. Using peat moss as a large part of the germination mix seems odd, in that the peat in a real bog would be deep and out of reach of the falling seeds, wouldn't they? So plants growing in sphagnum moss would probably fall and germinate on fresher moss, probably live. And, plants growing in sandy conditions would not naturally have a high percentage of peat in what they fall on. Maybe the tannins and other chemicals in the peat moss aren't the best for germinating seeds? I dunno...I'm just reaching out trying to grab the ring as I ride this merry-go-round. :?

When I first started out trying to grow from seed I held back a few seeds as "insurance". I kept doing this out of habit. I think I'm going to start planting the entire envelope. That way if I get a few plants to mature I can then do leaf cuttings....those have worked well for me with filiformis and I figure would work well with other drosera.

Maybe some of the folks that are good at starting seeds could post there techniques for us mere mortals to ponder over. :D
User avatar
By evenwind
Location: 
Posts:  2033
Joined:  Sun Jul 07, 2013 4:16 pm
#427549
I don't claim to be good at starting seeds but I do get a decent number of seedlings. I've kinda given up on trying to find a magical way of guaranteeing germination. I've tried various media, heat and humidity variation and water germination. I've had success with all and failures with all, too. Most frustratingly, I've got plants that produce a lot of seeds in my conditions but none of the seeds will germinate in those very same conditions! There are just too many variables, especially with seeds that have braved the USPS. Basically, at this point, I use a lot of seeds per pot (I'm currently using finely chopped LFS as a topcoat) and put the pot in my normal growing area. I seem to get as much germination without doing anything special as I did with my experimental trials. Just as an aside, when I do get germination, I favor the few larger growing seedlings to help them outgrow their siblings. I'm looking for 3 or 4 large adults, not a swarm of 30 mediocre ones.
Intheswamp liked this
User avatar
By Intheswamp
Location: 
Posts:  2369
Joined:  Wed May 04, 2022 2:28 pm
#427638
Do you bag or dome your pots, evenwind? If you do have them covered for germination when do you remove the cover? I like the idea of pampering the studs of the crop. I'm like you, I don't want (or need) a field of plants, just a few. Then, if I want more I can do leaf-cuttings. But, I gotta get them to the mature stage first. I read where someone (you?) had used a blender to finely chop up the LFSM...I haven't seen my wife use ours in years...I hope it's still stuck back on a shelf somewhere. ;)

The best baby plants that I've grown I grew from leaf-cuttings of a filiformis. I grew these in roughly 1-1/2" of BetterGro LFSM under about the same depth of live sphagnum moss....cuttings laying on the live moss. I might try this with some drosera seeds and see what happens.
User avatar
By evenwind
Location: 
Posts:  2033
Joined:  Sun Jul 07, 2013 4:16 pm
#427652
I've tried bagging as part of the humidity experiments. I could never walk the fine line between too dry and too wet successfully. I typically wound up with a lovely crop of green slime and/or abundant carpet moss. (I'm sure if I was trying to grow moss, I'd wind up with a crop of date palms or sequoias or something.) So, no, I don't bag. I figure the microclimate just above the chopped sphagnum is enough to get something started.

BTW, here's the thread where I talked about my sphagnum chopper. http://www.flytrapcare.com/phpBB3/post4 ... ml#p423596
Intheswamp liked this
By Bug_cemetery
Posts:  187
Joined:  Tue Mar 08, 2022 11:48 pm
#427655
I’m so curious about the idea of a sphagnum microclimate! My incredibly non scientific observation has been that I have better luck with rooting cuttings on sphagnum and getting seedlings to germinate in a tray with live sphagnum in the bottom (seeds are sown in small pots on standard peat-sand) so it sounds like the chopped sphagnum top dressing should be my next experiment!
Bluefire, I guarantee that I would forget and dry out a seedling pot too if it was all on its own. I put them in a 1020 tray with a tall dome that has a bottom layer of live sphagnum which seems to help regulate the humidity. I only check them once a week at most with this setup.
User avatar
By Intheswamp
Location: 
Posts:  2369
Joined:  Wed May 04, 2022 2:28 pm
#427783
I've been thinking about how a plant growing in the wild plants its seeds. I wouldn't think seeds would drop onto peat moss, being as in a bog the peat would be far below the surface (relative to size of the seed). So, the seed would likely land on live sphagnum moss or some type of sandy/organic(I think we refer to it as peaty) mix. I've only seen three types of drosera growing in the wild. Brevifolia and capillaris which were both in a tightly packed sandy soil with speckles of dark matter mixed in...a shallow layer of sphagnum moss was growing nearby both of these but they were not growing in it...only out of the bare sandy soil close to it. The other drosera was a filiformis which was growing out of a spongy sphagnum moss bog. All locations were "bottom" or "basin" like areas with seepage areas within them. Very humid. These are just my own, *very limited* experiences with wild growing plants and I feel other people probably have witnessed these species growing in much different environments. But, having seen this it tends to make me think that rosette, flat-growing plant seeds would benefit from the sandy/"peaty" mix and that taller, arial-growing plant seeds may benefit from live sphagnum moss. The seeds fall at the parent plants feet...and under an open sky.

Having stated the above, my first batch of brevifolia natively was in sandy/organic(?) soil but I transplanted them to a peat/sand mix...they died. But...one or two of the plants had seed stalks and a month or two later I started seeing tiny red specks appearing. So, apparently they *can* handle peat moss ok. And, @KategoricalKarnivore , in another thread stated that brevifolia grows close to him and they grew in a sandy area close to him and that he used a rough 2:1 sand-to-peat mix with good success. So, maybe the peat is ok...dunno. :? :?:

Thanks to the comments above from evenwind and Bug_cemetery I think I know what I'm going to do next with my stock of live sphagnum...make a germination/nursery chamber from it! :) It won't hurt the sphagnum moss, but it'll be "earning its keep"! :lol: It makes sense. I'm thinking if I can find a tall container so that I have maybe six inches or so above the growing mix surface that that would create a good, humid zone above the plants while still allowing a free exchange of air. Those milk-shake covers with the big hole in the top come to mind...but on a larger scale. Maybe a tall disposable cake cover with a large hole in the center covering the sphagnum moss container. Planted pots nestled down into the sphagnum moss and covered/surrounded by the vented top.

Thanks to the link to the chopper, evenwind!

Oh well, guess I've been rambling enough... :lol:

@Nikson , have you tried taking a white napkin/pap[…]

I use BioAdvanced Rose and Flower Insect Killer fo[…]

Immediately isolate it from other plants. Spray wi[…]

Uh you didn't list a price for the typical. Unless[…]

Hey gang, Wanted to check something with this lit[…]

First Orchid, Second On It's Way

If the orchid bug really gets a hold of you, rea[…]

Fall is here, and as we look forward toward winter[…]

Support the community - Shop at FlytrapStore.com!