Page 2 of 3

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2019 6:02 pm
by jasonh
Samsung in-Flux series should be great if anyone wants to DIY grow lights. Pretty expensive strips though.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2019 6:50 pm
by SundewWolf
jasonh wrote:Samsung in-Flux series should be great if anyone wants to DIY grow lights. Pretty expensive strips though.
Which series? All I’m seeing that’s acceptable is the T series that can be tuned to 6500k

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2019 7:23 pm
by nimbulan
SundewWolf wrote:
jasonh wrote:Samsung in-Flux series should be great if anyone wants to DIY grow lights. Pretty expensive strips though.
Which series? All I’m seeing that’s acceptable is the T series that can be tuned to 6500k
Why would you say that? A color temperature of 6500k isn't necessary or even ideal for indoor growing. I primarily use Samsung's H series strips myself @4000k, though I just bought some Q series as the cost has come down.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2019 11:58 pm
by SundewWolf
nimbulan wrote: Why would you say that? A color temperature of 6500k isn't necessary or even ideal for indoor growing. I primarily use Samsung's H series strips myself @4000k, though I just bought some Q series as the cost has come down.
A guy last week was telling me that anything under 6500K "severely reduces the usable light for the plants". I started this thread after buying 4000K 30W LED strips and being told they were completely useless, and I honestly don't know what each of the specifics need to be after hearing mixed advice for years.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Thu Mar 07, 2019 12:58 am
by nimbulan
SundewWolf wrote:
nimbulan wrote: Why would you say that? A color temperature of 6500k isn't necessary or even ideal for indoor growing. I primarily use Samsung's H series strips myself @4000k, though I just bought some Q series as the cost has come down.
A guy last week was telling me that anything under 6500K "severely reduces the usable light for the plants". I started this thread after buying 4000K 30W LED strips and being told they were completely useless, and I honestly don't know what each of the specifics need to be after hearing mixed advice for years.
Yeah that's complete BS. All visible light is usable by plants. I think most people get that idea into their head because 6500k is the approximate color temperature of sunlight and natural sunlight is obviously ideal. But when lacking the IR and UV components of the spectrum as is typically the case with artificial lights, it turns out that plants tend to grow a bit better (still not a large difference) with a lower color temperature.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Thu Mar 07, 2019 5:08 am
by SundewWolf
Sounds good. In this case what I have should be fine and I'm throwing on the some of those amazon blue LED panels.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Thu Mar 07, 2019 9:42 pm
by Doublebass1985
Basically when it comes down to it everyone thinks their advice is the correct way and any other way is wrong or won't work. The only way to eliminate this is to experiment and try different setups for yourself I know that could be costly and possibly waste in money, but I guess proof can be shown in pictures with what color temperature can grow healthy plants. Pretty much you should be able to grow plants on any kind of lights except incadscents.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Fri Mar 08, 2019 2:10 am
by nimbulan
Doublebass1985 wrote:Basically when it comes down to it everyone thinks their advice is the correct way and any other way is wrong or won't work. The only way to eliminate this is to experiment and try different setups for yourself I know that could be costly and possibly waste in money, but I guess proof can be shown in pictures with what color temperature can grow healthy plants. Pretty much you should be able to grow plants on any kind of lights except incadscents.
The funny thing is, incandescents have the most natural light spectrum of any artificial lights. The only reason we don't use them is that the electrical efficiency is so poor (and they have a pretty short lifetime.) In an enclosed space they'd just cook your plants.

And you're absolutely right. People really do tend to get stuck with the "my way is the only way" idea. It's very rare for a grower to properly experiment to determine how much a particular light fixture (or any other aspect of cultivation) improves their plant health compared to another light. I personally just go based off scientific research I've read and aim for the highest electrical efficiency I can.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 09, 2019 2:44 pm
by jasonh
SundewWolf wrote:
jasonh wrote:Samsung in-Flux series should be great if anyone wants to DIY grow lights. Pretty expensive strips though.
Which series? All I’m seeing that’s acceptable is the T series that can be tuned to 6500k
H-inFlux; I think they are pretty much the old F series with LM301B, from 3000k to 5000k.

For now I'll stick with Bridgelux EB Gen 2s until the price of samsung strips go down a bit or EB gen 3 comes out :)

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 09, 2019 5:26 pm
by jasonh
BTW Samsung just released their horticulture linear module a few month ago; haven't seen anyone selling those yet but most likely won't be cheap.

You can find the datasheet here:
https://cdn.samsung.com/led/file/resour ... ev.0.1.pdf

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 09, 2019 8:47 pm
by nimbulan
jasonh wrote:BTW Samsung just released their horticulture linear module a few month ago; haven't seen anyone selling those yet but most likely won't be cheap.

You can find the datasheet here:
https://cdn.samsung.com/led/file/resour ... ev.0.1.pdf
Yeah I was going to mention those before but as they aren't available yet...not much we can do about it. I will be very curious about the pricing.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 16, 2019 12:45 am
by SundewWolf
So i have heard that the blue light is for vegetative growth and red for flowering for years now which made me think about getting pure blue LED panels for years, but after watching this video I may just go with those purple (red+Blue) lights everyone is getting instead of the pure blue.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwwLSgK-924

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 16, 2019 1:51 am
by nimbulan
SundewWolf wrote:So i have heard that the blue light is for vegetative growth and red for flowering for years now which made me think about getting pure blue LED panels for years, but after watching this video I may just go with those purple (red+Blue) lights everyone is getting instead of the pure blue.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwwLSgK-924
Just ignore anything that talks about "veg" and "bloom" spectrums. Those were designed for marijuana growing where keeping the plants compact and maximizing flower mass are the intended goals. They were never meant for general plant growing.

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 16, 2019 2:02 am
by SundewWolf
nimbulan wrote:
SundewWolf wrote:So i have heard that the blue light is for vegetative growth and red for flowering for years now which made me think about getting pure blue LED panels for years, but after watching this video I may just go with those purple (red+Blue) lights everyone is getting instead of the pure blue.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwwLSgK-924
Just ignore anything that talks about "veg" and "bloom" spectrums. Those were designed for marijuana growing where keeping the plants compact and maximizing flower mass are the intended goals. They were never meant for general plant growing.
Between the pure blue LED vs. the red & blue mix LED's which would be better though? Should I ignore the results in the video?

Re: How big of a factor is the Wattage of LEDs?

Posted: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:12 am
by nimbulan
SundewWolf wrote:
nimbulan wrote:
SundewWolf wrote:So i have heard that the blue light is for vegetative growth and red for flowering for years now which made me think about getting pure blue LED panels for years, but after watching this video I may just go with those purple (red+Blue) lights everyone is getting instead of the pure blue.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwwLSgK-924
Just ignore anything that talks about "veg" and "bloom" spectrums. Those were designed for marijuana growing where keeping the plants compact and maximizing flower mass are the intended goals. They were never meant for general plant growing.
Between the pure blue LED vs. the red & blue mix LED's which would be better though? Should I ignore the results in the video?
Well the results of that video are basically: Don't use solid blue. They have another video showing white and red/blue being about the same, so why opt for the weird colors?