FlytrapCare Carnivorous Plant Forums

Sponsored by

Talk about anything you want in this forum.

Moderator: Matt

User avatar
By Supercazzola
Posts:  410
Joined:  Sun Nov 22, 2020 1:57 am
I find it very frustrating to not know where folks are located in. It creates unnecessary chatter back and forth, either in private messages or in the discussions themselves. If someone is asking for advice, but their Winter is actually different because they are in Australia, for example, that is pertinent.

What are your thoughts on making location info (even if down to the state / territory / province / prefecture ) mandatory for the forum profiles?

I am not suggesting they need to put a city down (but that is how Apollyon and I found out we lived like 5 miles apart), but having location info is very helpful. Not meaning to infringe on folks’ privacy in any way, but come on...
User avatar
By Apollyon
Posts:  1109
Joined:  Tue May 05, 2020 2:49 am
Hemisphere or state would definitely help. I can understand the reservations about cities. It was pretty awesome how that worked out with us though. General locations would at least help us avoid pulling teeth (we've all spoken to one at one time or another) or inadvertently condemning a plant to death. Certain areas within the same territory can be vastly different. Knocks a pre-req question out right away. Would also help with transactions. I'll often get a message asking me for a total +shipping for X plants and I'll usually have to say "Depends where you're located." I'm personally about efficiency so I can relate to this post.
Supercazzola liked this
By DragonsEye
Posts:  267
Joined:  Sat Oct 01, 2016 1:22 pm
While I can understand where knowing a poster's location could be helpful, I don't see making it "mandatory" going over well with many people. Having it as "optional" is about the most a forum can/should do.
By Mawy_Plants
Posts:  396
Joined:  Tue Jul 25, 2017 5:23 am
I know in the past there was a thread where members stated either their location and/or hardy zone. I find hardy zones a very helpful reference since they give you an idea of climate as a whole since I noticed cities sometimes have slightly different conditions/ micro climates depending on zip code. At least with hardy zone, there's still location privacy if that's a concern.

Happy Growing!
Supercazzola liked this
User avatar
By ChefDean
Posts:  3018
Joined:  Tue Sep 18, 2018 12:44 am
I'm not for it being mandatory, because most people will push back if told that they must do it. With it being a suggestion, many people will do it because they were given a choice.
I'm neutral on putting it out to ask everyone if they would update their profile to show their location because all anyone has to do is make a seed bank request and I voluntarily give you my address. However, if anyone gets any funny ideas, I live in a military town, and all of my immediate neighbors are active military that keep an eye on our little street. If you happen to get past them, my house is protected by Colt, Ruger, Winchester, Browning, J.C. Higgins, Savage, and Huglu. (Those aren't the names of my dogs)
Just sayin'.

For the past two years i tell myself every time i […]

Does the hose-end one have a label or gauge that g[…]

New in ctv

I am new on this page i hope learn more about in v[…]

Confirm My Suspicions Please

Remove the baby division in the winter and pot it […]

upcycling food containers

IIRC most banana cultivars are sterile, or only p[…]

Dog Pee

I tried to avoid issues with my dog's urine harmin[…]

S. 'Hot Lips' x 'Kraken'

This is the first Sarr that I got from Xanthoparme[…]

Nepenthes Ventricosa x Lowii 'red'

My last tobaica leaf jump was double, and the four[…]

Support the community - Shop at!