FlytrapCare Carnivorous Plant Forums

Sponsored by FlytrapStore.com

Got a carnivorous plant and you don't know what it is? Ask here!

Moderator: Matt

By balimynah
Posts:  12
Joined:  Wed Aug 15, 2012 1:45 pm
#151376
255242_402718909775335_1347889011_n.jpg
255242_402718909775335_1347889011_n.jpg (57.86 KiB) Viewed 4430 times
hello people, I'm new to this forum, my first post! :D
getting some dionaeas from a nursery here in India, all the clones were mixed up hence the seller does not know the exact names of the cultivars, I'm posting pics of 2. please help me id them. thanks!
Attachments:
189406_402718873108672_833337935_n.jpg
189406_402718873108672_833337935_n.jpg (60.07 KiB) Viewed 4429 times
By Darkrai283
Posts:  2491
Joined:  Fri Jul 30, 2010 2:28 pm
#151379
I'm sorry, but if I I'd not come with a label stating it as a specific type of VFT, it has to be classified as a 'typical'.

If you read this topic made by forum moderator 'Veronis', it might help clear things up a little bit about classification as well. LINK :)

Welcome to the Flytrapcare forums! :D
By balimynah
Posts:  12
Joined:  Wed Aug 15, 2012 1:45 pm
#151411
hi Darkrai, the seller said these are not the typical VFTs but some premium clones. he had got a huge lot of diffrent clones but unfortunately all got mixed up and he was able to find out the proper names of the clones.
By Darkrai283
Posts:  2491
Joined:  Fri Jul 30, 2010 2:28 pm
#151414
balimynah wrote:hi Darkrai, the seller said these are not the typical VFTs but some premium clones. he had got a huge lot of diffrent clones but unfortunately all got mixed up and he was able to find out the proper names of the clones.
Unfortunately, with no labels or any other form of classification, you will have to call it a 'typical'.
balimynah wrote:the seller said these are not the typical VFTs but some premium clones
Is s/he a reputable seller? If not, it may have just been a scam to sell the plants quickly and maybe, at a higher price than usual.
By Veronis
Posts:  2200
Joined:  Fri May 29, 2009 8:41 pm
#151487
I believe that they could very well be named cultivars, but due to the genetics of venus flytraps and how random their appearance is (they are not like multi-species plants where ID'ing is possible via photos), Darkrai is right - you will never be able to ID the cultivar and label it.

Look here, and you will see that there are hundreds upon hundreds of cultivars out there, and so many of them look the same at a glance that it would be impossible for anyone to tell you what cultivar those flytraps are.

Bottom line: Pitcher plants, sundews, and butterworts can be ID'd via photos - flytraps, unfortunately, cannot.

Don't worry about the fact that you can't label them (I know I know, easier said than done...sorry for the bad news). Those flytraps, however, do look like very healthy young flytraps. My favorite flytrap in my collection is actually one of my seed-growns. Even if those aren't cultivars, which you'll never know, that doesn't make them inferior to cultivars. For example, I personally think Red Dragon is a rather unimpressive red cultivar. It's slow-growing, lanky/weak looking, and in my experience a fairly poor seeder. I have a red seed-grown that's better than a red dragon in every way. "Cultivar" does not make a flytrap "premium" - premium is a matter of opinion.

Do read my post - it may give you more insight, and possibly ideas on which flytrap cultivars you may want next (I list quite a few cultivars), which you would then be able to label if you attain them from a reputable source.
Veronis liked this
By sbrooks
Posts:  748
Joined:  Tue May 22, 2012 3:33 pm
#151489
So, how would you know if you obtained a fake? Is there some Mona Lisa test, or something?
By Veronis
Posts:  2200
Joined:  Fri May 29, 2009 8:41 pm
#151490
Purchasing from reputable sellers or trading with reputable growers is the only way to be sure.

Some flytraps are easier to identify than others, to be fair. E.g. If you buy a Biohazard, you're probably getting a Biohazard.

Many cultivars look just too similar enough to others (or seed-growns, for that matter) to be ID'd via photos.
Veronis liked this
By sbrooks
Posts:  748
Joined:  Tue May 22, 2012 3:33 pm
#151492
Thank, Veronis. Just to belabor the subject ad nauseum: Can an experienced grower identify, say, a Big Mouth, or a B52, or a DC XL, if the plant is in front of him? I realize the answer to this question could be a touchy subject, should you draw the conclusion that anyone can be fooled by a fake, and that it would be easy to pass a fake off on just about anybody. Are you saying that the only way to determine pedigree is with the "paperwork"?
By Veronis
Posts:  2200
Joined:  Fri May 29, 2009 8:41 pm
#151494
sbrooks wrote:Just to belabor the subject ad nauseum:
That phrase made me lol

There are some growers that can identify a flytrap from photos, but generally only the more unique ones. And even then, who's to say it isn't a seed-grown that happens to look similar?

If a flytrap is in front of an experienced grower, it won't really help much compared to detailed photos. B52, DC XL, and Big Mouth are just not unique enough to positively ID in an unlabeled pot. Even unique flytraps like Pom Pom and Biohazard can't be identified 100%, as any flytrap can mimic these mutations, but later show other traits that give them away as not the cultivar they pretended to be.

We could theoretically look at the trap size of a possible DC XL and assume it is what it is, based on all information (source, etc.), but it would still be an assumption. The most obvious answer of course would be to measure the mature traps, and even then, not all DC XL's/B52's traps are "max size", so you could easily be looking at a colorful seed-grown that looks like B52/Big Mouth or a large-trapped upright seed-grown that just tossed up a 1.9" trap, and since it looks like a DC XL, you then assume it's a DC XL. This is bad practice, though, and should never be done unless enough information is available to make a 100% certainty deduction.

An example: If you know that your flytrap is either "this" or "that", or even "one of these 6 cultivars", an experienced grower can sometimes deduce from there.

Another issue is growing conditions. A B52 in epic lighting will look far different than a B52 that only gets 3 hours of light per day. Color, size, growth, will all be different. Also, flytraps grown indoors can often look far different, especially coloration-wise, than flytraps grown in sunlight. How much they eat is also a factor (the less they eat, the more colorful they are).

Again, the key phrase here is reputable sources. I'm sure there are lots of mislabeled flytraps floating around out there.

Here are three flytraps. Which is B52 and which is Big Mouth?
Attachments:
p3.jpg
p3.jpg (109.47 KiB) Viewed 4381 times
p2.jpg
p2.jpg (79.58 KiB) Viewed 4381 times
p1.jpg
p1.jpg (145.38 KiB) Viewed 4381 times
Veronis, Veronis liked this
By sbrooks
Posts:  748
Joined:  Tue May 22, 2012 3:33 pm
#151504
Trick question. All three seed grown. (Actually, I haven't a clue). Anyway, thanks again for incredibly thorough, well thought out info. You truly know your "stuff", obviously have a passion for the subject matter, and are invaluable to the growers who visit this site. Thanks for your time!
User avatar
By Matt
Location: 
Posts:  21107
Joined:  Mon Apr 21, 2008 11:28 pm
#151512
I'll take a shot!
1) B52
2) Can't really tell from the photo because I can't see a full trap, but I'm going to guess Big Mouth
3) B52

I'm guessing that with a 50/50 chance to get each one right, I probably got one of the three right :)
By Veronis
Posts:  2200
Joined:  Fri May 29, 2009 8:41 pm
#151568
sbrooks was right, it was a trick question (sorry!) to illustrate the impossibility of ID'ing flytraps in most cases.

The flytraps pictured above, from top to bottom, are:
p3.jpg: Dionaea "G13"
p2.jpg: Dionaea "Clumping Cultivar"
p1.jpg: Dionaea "Big Jaws"


If, on the other hand, someone posted to the forum "I have this flytrap that I bought from FlytrapStore about 6 months ago. It's a cultivar but I lost the label and don't remember what it is! ID, anyone?"
and then showed this photo, we would be able to say with certainty that it is a Dionaea 'Korean Melody Shark'.
flytrap.jpg
flytrap.jpg (37.36 KiB) Viewed 4338 times
By balimynah
Posts:  12
Joined:  Wed Aug 15, 2012 1:45 pm
#151667
hi people, is he a rep seller? well he is the only seller of carnis in India and he won't cheat anyone for sure. i received the plants and the look nothing like my old typical green vfts..they were a bit damaged during transportation but are now showing growth so will post pics asap. thanks for all the help!
The best Long Fibered Sphagnum Moss

I’ve said this a couple times before, but th[…]

Five years after my first post in this thread I'[…]

Epiphytic utrics, Drosera for sale

how would you grow utricularia humboltii? I'm inte[…]

WTB Heliamphora

I have an extra division of heliamphora minor burg[…]

An Ant Invasion!

Sorry guys, haven't been on in awhile. @Dr Green[…]

Maxsea

I can trade a pinguicula agnata for the maxsea. ca[…]

Growing Vlt in Michigan

Hey everyone, I'm relatively new to growing vft a[…]

Are aquatic CP's that keep water trays clean?

I am wondering if anyone is familiar with any aqua[…]

Support the community - Shop at FlytrapStore.com!